can we stop for a while and just appreciate Minho's vocal here😍💕

Taemin's vocal is pretty really actually good.

2022年、このMV撮影をした結婚式場で写真を撮ってきた。自宅からそう遠くない場所だがジョンヒョンの事で数年行けなかった。鉢植えや何もかもを配置を変えずにこのまま残してくれていた。 挙式入り口ドア横にある旗は🚩少し劣化して色変わりしていたが、「いつでも入れるのでまた写真撮りに来て下さいね。」と親切に対応してくれた。夜は同じくライトアップされている。 ファンの方が今も訪れている様で、今でも当時のままの状態で残してくれて感謝。 撮影当日の話もしてくれて、丸1日かけて撮影していて疲れているだろうにメンバー達は終始この式場のスタッフさん達にずっと気遣いの暖かい言葉をかけてくれて、撮影当時スタッフさんはSHINeeの事は知らなかったけど、メンバー達の人柄・とても謙虚な姿勢・暖かい言葉など今でも忘れていないと。 中でも印象的だったのはジョンヒョンだったとか。。

This song is a masterpiece! beautiful voice JongHyun will be eternal!

MINHO'S VOCAL SLAYED

Can we just talk about how on point their visuals are? Like Wow.. They all look so beautiful and handsome. Especially Key. And Taemin. And Minho. And Jonghyun. And Onew.

どこのコメント欄でも みんなジョンヒョンの事をずっと好きでいてくれて覚えてくれていてお疲れ様と言ってあげていてたくさんいるシャヲルの中の1人の私だけど それがとてもとても嬉しい 私もジョンヒョンのこと一生忘れないよ ずっと大好きだよ ジョンヒョンの残してくれた10年間の足跡 これからも大切にずっと一緒に歩んでいくね

5 vocalist 5 visuals 5 talented boys 5 forever OT5

I'm sorry but MINHO!!! Can we all just take this precious moment of Minho hitting them notes like as if he wasn't criticized for his singing before. He is evolving!! This man knows how to take criticism and make up for them with a blast. WHO CAN'T SING IN SHINEE? WHO CAN'T?

I'm literally weeping on the floor. These vocals are going to be the death of me. Jonghyun who has worked so hard up until now, Taem who used to be called tone deaf, Onew who used to crack his voice a lot, Key, whose haters said his voice was deteriorating, and Minho who everyone doubted. Look at them now, all slaying the life out of everyone. Makes me want to sob forever.

who's doing shinee marathon? their japanese songs are so beautiful :')

this song is magical! SHINee has the best vocals ever known. Jonghyun is amazing as always!

Onew's voice

tHESE END OF THE YEAR COMEBACKS ARE KILLING ME OMG

小学校低学年の物心ついていない時から大好きだった。初めて好きになったグループ。こんなに大好きな歌声を姿を見ることが聞くことがあの日から出来なかった。だけどふと5人の姿が見たくなってLIVEを見ました。どこか寂しくて涙が止まらなかったけどやっぱり永遠に5人がSHINeeが大好きです。 こんな綺麗な声を存在を忘れない。

ジョンヒョン 。。。 Shineeは、最高のメンバー。 オニュ、キー、ミンホ、テミン。 心に寄り添える最高のグループだと思います。応援しています。

Onew killed me with his "Let it snow tonight" @3:46

SM doing what they do best, dropping MVs without any notice

こんな幸せな歌なのに、涙が止まらない。 正直、まだ5人のMVを見れない。現実をまだ受け入れられない。でも、12/18。この日だけは、5人のSHINeeを見る。あなたが最後まで望んだ形だから。これからも私の1番好きな人達は5人のSHINeeです。出会わせてくれて、出会ってくれてありがとう。

こんな感情を込めて歌うアーティストはSHINeeくらいしかいないよね。ほんとに感動する…いつまでも輝くSHINeeでいてください！大好きです…

Onew looks so beautiful in this one

army is here to support ;)

つい１ヶ月前にオンユのレイニーブルーをたまたまKZfaqで聞いてから、オンユの歌声に癒され、感動し、オンユから→SHINeeを知り今では毎日SHINeeの曲をたくさん聞くようになりました！ 五人の歌声、踊り、本当に素敵です！！ SHINee大好き！！

ずっとSHINee全て曲が聴けなくなってたけど、少しずつ聴けるようになってきました。 ただ、まだ聴くと泣いちゃう。 ジョンオッパが恋しいです。好きだった本当に。

Thats why i am a multifandom fan...shinee always slays the game

Minho finished a ballad T_T SHINee are truly 5 vocalists! Onews voice forever the highlight of kpop♡

Jonghyun. I want to talk about your musicality first. You possessed a talent that no other will be able to again. I love the power behind your voice. I love the way that you pronounce your words and how you choose to articulate your vocals. Your voice was so pure and thorough, and it is so evident how much passion you had for singing. You were born with a gift, with this instrument and you managed to master it and share it through various styles of songs. I love that your voice could adapt to whatever concept or style that you were met with, and you were able to diversify your lines without losing the qualities that define your voice. There was so much life behind your voice and I really believe it was the foundation of Shinee songs. It is simply so pure and authentic, which makes it all the more honoring to be able to listen to. You were meant to be singing and warming hearts with your voice. At the same time, you were one of the most phenomenal dancers that I knew. You danced in such a way that made you stand out when executing these, while still blending in with the rest of your members. It is so easy to watch you dance because of the how naturally you moved. When you were on stage, you moved so flawlessly and so comfortably. You moved in a way that demonstrated your personal expression, but still showed all of the characteristics of Shinee’s choreographies. You paid so much attention to all of the details, and your facial expressions are included there as well. You brought Shinee’s choreographies to life and infused into them so much of your experience and professionalism as a dancer. Overall, I hope you know how legendary of an artist you were and will always be. You are the reason we have music the way we do today, and we needed your contributions to help create its future. You will forever be modeled after and your musical persona will continue to be passed on for years to come. As much as your musicality will always be cherished, your personality will be as well, I know that nobody will hold onto it quite like your members. I can say so confidently that you have freed your members. One of the first reasons I came to figure this out is how vulnerable you have always been with them. I know you dealt with so much and felt so many conflicting emotions, and you must have seen something really valuable in your members to trust those feelings with them. It is so evident in how close you all were because of how you’ve confided in them and believed in them since the very beginning of your time today. Because of the time they spent with you and the way that you made them feel, they see the significance in living their lives with no fear. They look up to you because of how resilient and stable you were, all while knowing what you were dealing with. Look at all they’ve accomplished. It is simply because of the life you led that they are able to follow you and do the same. It is you who has strengthened the already unbreakable bond that you all had, and established the familial connection that you all share even further. Your members believe in each other and believe in staying together forever in order to honor you. Every action they take is in your name, and I hope you know that you could not have shown them a greater love. You are the reason they are who they are and that they can live their lives without being held back by anything. Thank you for every second that you spent showing them the greatest love imaginable. I want to personally thank your parents and family for raising you and helping you to become the talented, selfless, and inspiring man that you turned out to be. I know that they are likely the reason you were able to hold on for so long and I know that they meant the world to you. The influence they had on your life is so grand and cannot be missed. I want to give them my condolences on behalf of all of your other loved ones, but I want to thank them more so for continuing to live out your legacy. I hope you know that you could never disappoint them and all they ever will feel for you is pride. They will always understand you and love you more than anybody else on this Earth, and they live each day continuing what you started. I thank them for continuing to honor you with all that they do; and for spreading the same generosity and love that you did. Your fans keep your family in our hearts always and forever, and will follow their lead in extending your influence in the most respectable way. On the topic of generosity, it is your fans who you likely showed the most grace to; the reason being that you always put us before yourself. You dealt with more than you ever should have, and you still made time to make sure that we were entertained and happy. All we could have ever hoped for was you taking time that you needed, because just knowing you were there was enough for us. Just your presence was enough for us to feel comfortable and content in our own skin, but you did much more than just be there for us every day. You put in so much work just to make sure we had a piece of you to hold on to; and you never had to exert yourself just to please us. I only hope that in the time that you spent with us, you found us being as supportive as possible. I hope that you did not feel obligated to work hard for us, because as I mentioned earlier, just having you around was all we ever wanted. You put your soul into all that you did for us, and we felt it through every form of communication. You always shared how you were feeling; at least as much as you were comfortable with, and this is all more than you ever had to do. I hope that we were able to offer you at least some relief, because it was you who was saving us each and every day. There are so many fans who are who they are because of the life that you’ve shown us. I hope you don’t feel guilt because similarly to your members, you couldn’t have loved us better and shown us a better life. We could not exist without the love that you continue to show us even without being with us. We will never forget what you’ve done for us and we will continue to live our lives with you in our hearts as we live day to day. Thank you for changing our lives and helping us become who we were meant to be. I know you’ve been through a lot, both professionally and personally. What we know of is likely not even the beginning of the burdens you had to carry. I know that anybody could agree with me when I say that you are easily one of the strongest people for persevering through what you did for so long. It is the hate and the disregard for human life that drove you to make your decision, and I hope you know that we acknowledge the effect that this can have on a person. I know we will never fully understand just what you had to deal with, but we are aware of how strong you had to be to be able to stand up to it even at all. Again, this is just part of what you had to deal with, but you struggled through it with an open heart for so long. I know that facing these fears and hardships helped you to understand more about yourself and you were able to benefit from taking that leap of faith in the end. No matter if you were were a Shinee supporter or not, everybody can learn from how you decided to address what was ailing you. You have taught us not only how to interact with our problems, but also how to treat others in our lives as well. I thank you so much for putting up with what you did and for being so rigid through all of it. It is not easy to brush off those feelings, but you kept your head up for so long, and we are so beyond proud of you for the strength and resilience you’ve shown for the entirety of your life span. You teach us all with your lifestyle choices every single day. I hope you know that your loved ones are all taking this day to commemorate you and the wonderful person that you became. You had a soul too pure for this world, and today, as well as every other day, we recognize and celebrate who you were. I hope you are able to realize just how monumental and historic you are for so many people. It may be hard to view yourself in this way, but just know that your fans and family are going to celebrate your life on this very special day just for you. We will live this day exactly how you would, with nothing but love for you and others in our hearts. Thank you for sacrificing so much just to make Shinee and your own personal creations possible. Thank you for suffering through any pain, fear, anger, confusion, defeat, fear, angst, concern, worry, doubt, fatigue, and so much more just to make us happy. I want you to know we recognize each and every one of your efforts, no matter how minuscule you might think they were. Remember, that they will always change somebody’s mood, day, and life somewhere in the world. Your impact on another’s heart is just that strong. You are the reason so many people believe in themselves and are who they are today, including your members, and I hope you do’t forget that. Thank you so much for your hard work and efforts. You will always be the light in this world, and though nobody is perfect, you will forever be beautiful inside and out to your loved ones. Your love is eternal and will continue to change this world for the better. You will never be forgotten and will forever be honored and remembered! Thank you kindly, great legend, and I hope you are at peace. I hope you found happiness and bliss beyond your wildest dreams. Happy birthday Jonghyun, and we adore you so much. You will always be missed, but celebrated more fiercely! We love you.

ふと思いだし聞きたくなる 聞き出すと何度も何度も繰り返し聞いてしまう 私を癒してくれてありがとう

LOOK AT BABY MINHO HITTIN THEM NOTES 😭💕 I'M SO SHOOK ✨ THANK YOU SM ❤️

OMG I'M SO PROUD OF MINHO. He killed those high notes! Why is nobody talking about him? Look at him. He's really gone better. I love you my minho 😍

ジョンヒョン元気ですか？ 貴方の歌声や笑い声や綺麗な顔立ち今でもずっと心の中にいます。 今もこらからも永遠にジョンヒョンを思い続けてます。ありがとう♥사랑해🌹

俺の中でk-popハマった理由はSHINeeのring ding dongやって初めて聞いた時の衝撃はんぱなくてその中でもジョンヒョンが1番かっこよかった いまジョンヒョンは空の上で綺麗な歌声届けてるかな？ 今ではいろんなアイドル出てきて歌がめっちゃ上手い子だっておるけどジョンヒョンの歌声は今もこれから先も色あせることはないよ 久しぶりにSHINee聴いて初心に帰れた気がする、ありがとう

Shinee keeps hitting me over and over with these blessings, I'm dyin here

Shinee is the only sm group that has no issue. Dbsk, SJ, snsd, , fx, and exo, some members left the group and sm. I hope hope hope with all my heart that nothing happens to shinee. I've cried enough for 2ne1, please don't break my heart with any bad news about shinee. I know I'm ranting but I'm scared. I thought certain groups will stay strong but it's unexpected. We never know what will happen so hopefully shinee will keep going strong. They are amazing and so talented. Their music is unique and I hope they will continue being a legend and stay together as 5. Forever a shawol. We love you, shinee!

歌詞で泣くのはあるけど歌声で涙が出るのはSHINeeが初めてです。5人のハーモニーが綺麗で毎日聴いてます。これからもジョンヒョンを感じながら曲を聴いていきます。SHINeeになってくれてありがとう。大好きです❤️

本当に✨素敵な曲だと思います。SHINeeの曲の中でも上位に入るくらい大好きな曲です🎶寒い冬に聴いたら心がほっこり来て💜暖かい気持ちになります。安定の名曲ですね💎✨💜

FORGET MAMA AWARD! SHINEE NEEDS TO WIN A GRAMMY!!

I love you most, Key. But i love you all really deep in the end.

ジョンヒョンの声に癒されてます。 ジョンヒョンの歌唱力は魅力的。亡くなっても、ずっと聴きつづけます。

冬になると聴きたくなるので、最近沢山聴いてます。5人の温かい歌声が大好きです。 5HINee Forever💎💎💎💎💎

MINHO'S BEAUTIFUL VOICE OMG I RARELY HEAR HIM SING IN THEIR KOREAN SONGS BUT HE GETS TO SING MORE FOR THEIR JAPANESE SONGS. ANYWAYS. MY KINGS MY LEGENDS I LOVE YOU BOYS SO MUCH YOU'RE ALL SO BEAUTIFUL AND TALENTED. SLAY ME

Kibum and Jinki, please stop destroying my heartu, my soul and my bias list 😵💘😍

東京ドーム公演からずっとSHINeeの曲聴いてる♪ 4人の曲ももちろん大好きなんだけど、5人の曲がすごく恋しくなってる。

When i say shinee has 5 main vocals i mean it

A ballad by Jonghyun and Minho would be great. Don't you think??

ok I became a Shawol after listening to "Tell Me What To Do". So here again ShiNee is back with a perfect song. Love love love love this song loads. ❤❤❤

Listening to SHINee's ballads and sheez. I'm loving every song.

毎年冬になると必ず聴きに来ます。 必ず涙が溢れます。ジョンヒョンが恋しいです。 時が流れるのは本当に早いですね。

I've never officially 'stanned' shinee but I've liked their music and can I just say that kim kibum is the most beautiful man I've ever seen I literally tear up when I see him he's so pretty

This army is in love with this song! Amazing vocals. They are so dkkdskdj 😍😍😍 SHINee fighting!! Minho.. i can't with him 😢

いつの日かコンビニで流れてて今更ながらハマってます…もっと早く出会いたかったな…笑

未だにここにこの季節になったらこの曲聞きに来てます。 1年前の出来事がまだ信じられないです。 LIVEに行ったこともなければイベントに伺ったこともない、 けど、SHINeeの事は知ってて、 5人の歌声が大好きで、 ジョンヒョンの作った曲も大好きで、 少し早く旅立ったことをとても悲しく思います。 天国で4人の輝きを活動を見てくれていると信じています。 生まれてきてくれて、 沢山素敵なものを残してくれて、 ありがとうございます。 これからもSHINeeを曲を愛し続けます。

exo-l here to support shinee i like this song and also jpop

I can't believe SHINee invented winter and all music

ホント歌が上手い。 世界観も素敵です。 何年経っても色褪せない曲。

今でも全ての曲が大好きなのはshineeだけです。 子どものように笑いはしゃぐジョンヒョン が大好きです。

Just wanted to share here that Minho was fanboying at jonghyuns concert yesterday ahaha ❤️

Fell in love on the first note

I'm so proud of Minho. His singing has improved so much since their debut. His solo line at the bridge was pure magic

SHINee Vocal Kings for a reason. This song is such a masterpiece

jinki's and minho's voice are so beautiful😍😍😍

MinHo is singing more and I'm so happy with it♡ But yesterday was like 32 C degrees and I'm here, feeling the winter(?)

Happpy 4th Anniversary, Winter Wonderland 💎 , time flies , it is Dec again, take care shawols

Ming's voice really shine in japanese songs❤️💎

SHINee has most beautiful songs in kpop world

I usually don't care for ballads but SHINee's is an exception. Love them!

冬になると思い出すずっと大好きな5人の曲

6年ぶりの東京ドーム公演を2日後に控えてまたここに来たけど。 やっぱりもう一度5人に会いたいよ💎

I love them SO MUCH DAMN IT! also finally our baby love minho gets to sing more

Jonghyun is very beautiful and his voice omg

シーパラのイルカショーでこの歌を聞き、とても心に残りました。

この時期になるとふと聴きたくなる。 5人のSHINeeが恋しくなる。

MINHO REALLY IMPROVED!

Quasimodo, Symptoms, An Encore, Close the Door, 1000 years, Don't Let Me Go, now this! SHINee ballads are just the best, they can play on your heartstrings.. 💓💕💔

2020になってSHINeeを知りSHINeeを好きになりました。これからもずっと好きです。

i miss you Jonghyun… I wish I could turn back time to meet u when SHINee hold a concert in Jakarta😢 :( thankyou for coming to my life, fulfil my energy during elementary school days…. 11 years ago you guys are my first group that I love… send hugs for all shawols and SHINee members. Be happy up there, Jjong❤

Onew be like "move over Elsa, Arendelle now has a prince"

Mature SHINee really reminds me of TVXQ during their Doushite era.

SHINee = kings of vocals ❤

Minho’s voice sounds extra warm when it's a Japanese song❤️

im ana EXO-l but this just popped up in my recommandations and I DONT REGRET CLICKING ON IT SHINEE SLAAYYY

all these gentlemen that are known as Shinee are very talented singers and dancers plus good actors and very good looking on top of all that. They sing good songs. One of the top kpop groups.☆☆☆☆☆♡♡♡♡♡ ps. they have very nice personalities very nice to other people.

shinee discography is unmatched for real

今までも、この曲が大好きだ。冬になってきた時、これを思い出す。Jonghyun, I miss you. Hope you always be happy and just be yourself at anywhere you go, don't be afraid, you are pretty soul in this universe.

I want to see them on variety shows again. I don't know why, but I'm missing shinee so much.. (silly me)

Full PV? That's surprising. I'm so in love with Taemin's voice in ballad

この曲が大好きです。親戚のお姉さんが好きだったSHINeeを初めて聞いた日から今18歳の冬までずっと聞いています。SHINeeのKZfaq欄にコメントするのは初めてですが沢山のファンの方がSHINeeを愛しているのがとても伝わる暖かいコメント欄でSHINeeのファンのみなさんもとても素敵なんですね。いつか大好きなkeyくんにライブでお会いしたいです。今年も沢山この曲を聞こうと思います。

My one of favorite Winter song

whenever Shinee sang a ballad song especially in Japanese I instantly fell in love with the song 😍😍😍 their Japanese Ballad is so great 👍👍👍

MINHO'S HIGH NOTE!!! 💗 💗 💗 💗 AAAAAAHHHHH I LOVEEEEE

これからの季節にピッタリの名曲。切なくあたたかくて、愛しい誰かをしっかりと抱きしめたくなるような曲。

This song is so beautiful ❤️

I'm crying this is so beautiful. How can you not cry?

MINHO voice is so amazing....very much improving..shinee always slay..awesome .. minho you melt my busy day.. shinee.. amazing.. i hope they have a English version.. its my wish.. so toucçhing voice and song.. unstoppable listening ...

Shinee has one of the best harmonies in kpop. Its just so powerful that seems so seamless when they harmonize, will give you chills.

I am a new fan and their japanese songs just hit different

I joined K-pop during the year where shinee, b2st, and big bang were huge hits. they are truly the groups that I believe has a talent that no other K-pop group could compare to and shinee from their part never fails to show that. lots of love for them.

This is the true ballad Shinee.. I mean I like Tell me what to do I really do but when SM said Shinee is gonna have ballad title song for their repackage I was expecting something like this. Just listen Minho singing beautifully instead of having some awkward rap part.

Still I love this song❤👏 SHINee the best love y'all.❤❤❤💪

必ず冬になると聴きたくなる曲。 ジョンヒョンが亡くなる1年前の SHINeeのコンサートで 1番最後に歌ってくれた曲で いまもジョンヒョンのあの時の姿、笑顔を思い出します。 テミンが1番好きだった私ですが ジョンヒョンの綺麗なあたたかな笑顔が 印象的で、一緒に行った母と帰り道もジョンヒョンの話で盛りたがったのを思い出します。 ほんと綺麗な素敵な人でした。 サビの "Winter Wonderland 君といま願い込めた夜空 冬があたたかいって思った" ここの歌詞、メロディーが好きで なんだか泣きそうにいつもなります