I really miss this song.. thank you Ningning for covering this song, it really reminds me how I am obssess with this song

Just come here after Ningning preview, I love this version the most! Krystal voice is so mesmerizing

My favorite version personally. Taeyeon x Jonghyun sounds like husband and wife who's been together for 10 years but decided to broke up. Chen and Liyin sounds like two great loves that did not last for long BUT this version feels like a first love that NEVER even get into fruition. Like both of them never knew the feelings of the other. The kind of first love you would always have a thought of "what if I confessed back then? Would our lives be different?"

I miss her singing to be honest. and I love how SM chose them to duet because their voices match and support each other ( in my opinion ). I wish for more of their collaboration, and I wish SM will show more of Soojung's range, just like what Amber said in her podcast. anyways don't forget to watch Changmin's new MV - Chocolate!!!!!!

何年振りかな ふと聴きたくなってまた涙 この歌はどうしても チャンミンとクリスタルのバージョンが好きなの。

Check out S.M.THE BALLAD Vol.2 BREATH(JPN ver.) Music Video!

いつまで経っても大好きな曲。今でも韓国語VERだけはカラオケにあるので日本語で歌います。本当に大好き

krystal voice really similar with her sister. oh i miss jessica T_T

So many Krystal comments! Can we appreciate how perfect Changmin sounds here?

はぁ、、久しぶりに聴きに来たらやっぱ泣きそうになった チャンミンずっとだいすき、

Changmin and Krystal - soft, sweet vocals Jonghyun and Taeyeon - powerful vocals Chen and Zhang Li Yin - harmonious vocals SM Daebak!

I mean Changmin is getting married in September, look how time flies.

Why changmin so handsome?😨😂😂😂

もうこれが8年前？時間経つの早すぎ 私が高校生の時どハマりしたよ 今も聴いてる大好きな曲🥺

just missing those days when SM just actively made tons of collaborations among their talents. like for real, it was the best era.

Do i ever mentioned how goodlooking changmin?? 😍😍😍😚

Krystal is nice. Her voice is nice. Her attitude is nice. She's not cold or arrogant, she's just shy around strangers. If you watch Jessica & Krystal reality show, they explained why they were quite on stage. Don't judge if you don't know fully about her. Don't judge her. You might make a fool out of yourself. If you don't like Krystal, then don't watch it. Just my opinion.

Changmin is mastered at Japanese..his pronounciation just perfect,, Krystal-ssi ganbatte!

Krystal's voice is very like Jessica :))

I don't why this is suddenly on my recommendation but #WelcomebackidolKrystal

I really love Krystal's voice here, it really blends with Changmin's. Each version has a different feel to it, almost like you're really listening to a completely different song instead of just a different version.

Changmin in this MV reminded me of him back in the day when DBSK were still as five...around the Banjun drama time, it feel innocent

Krystal's soft voice really fits the ballad. I'm glad they chose her for this..

Krystal's very BEAUTIFUL. And her voice's really similar to Jessica.

ChangMin really rocked this song! His voice and style suits this song the best. Chen and Jonghyun did a great job too! But in terms of experience with lyrics in different language, ChangMinnie has tonnes. His younger-power-vocal hoobaes may need some time to get to this level.

I wanted to see Changmin&BoA because BoA's Japanese is really good

it's been 9 years since the version was released, and I am still fall in love with Japanese version. both Krystal and Changmin were my bias in their respective group. listening back to this song make me wish if there was rehearsal or live version for this song

The guy is perfect. I love his voice.

i just love staring at krystal's solo shots :) so pretty! changmin's expression is really good. as expected from dbsk ;>

Krystal sounds EXACTLY like jessica omg best sisters ever

heard all the versions before watching the mvs. i especially like this one because i get the emotions. changmin and krystal sang it really well despite their different color of voice. ah this is good... sm songs in japanese sounds nice.

God, I need Krystal solo like, right now! Your voice is so beautiful, baby Soojungie. So soothing n you can deliver the feel of the song really well. Now I'm crying 😭😍😭

When Changmin started crying at the end when he finally saw the girl, I started crying, too. It was so sad omg. Changmin is quadruple threat: singer, dancer, actor, model.

テクニックに、たよらないストレートな癖のない発音の歌が心にひびきます。 演技も表情で魅せてくれて、キュンとなりました。

すごいクリスタルの歌声がジェシカに似てる！ さすが姉妹…♡めっちゃいい歌…

Changmin's voice is so lovely. No wonder Japanese people loves and appreciates TVXQ.

Changmin really sings so well. He is particullarly good at expressing in Japanese.

SM I DARE YOU TO MAKE ENGLISH VERSION OF THIS BALLAD SONG "BREATH" BY: D.O & WENDY PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEE

I have never listened a voice like Changmin´s voice before, so powerful, beautiful, with color and `personality`. I´m so proud of being his fan

BREATH 出てはいけないと分かっていたのに deteha ikenaito wakatteitanoni やあ久しぶりだね ya hisashiburidane 電話の声が 震えてすぐに denwanokoega huruetesuguni 後悔が ため息へと 変わっていく koukaiga tameikieto kawatteiku 出てくれる訳ないと 思ってたから detekureru wakenaito omottetakara ごめん 声にならないの gomen koeninaranaino 今どこで 何しているかも imadokode nanishiteirukamo 聞けなくて 涙が出る kikenakute namidagaderu 想いが 言葉にならない omoiga kotobaninaranai 耳に 響く 息の音 mimini hibiku ikinooto 元気だよと 嘘をつくのも genkidayoto usootukunomo 優しさだと 分かっているけど yasashisadato wakatteirukedo 吐息だけでも いいから toikidakedemo iikara 今夜だけ 聴かせてほしい　このまま konyadake kikasetehoshii konomama ねえ君は新しい恋を　もう始めたんだね nee kimihaatarasiikoiwo mo majimetandane あなたより素敵な人　なんて anatayori sutekinahito nante いないのに　心を騙して inainoni kokorowodamashite 虚しい恋しているよ munashiikoishiteiruyo 耳に 響く 息の音 mimini hibiku ikinooto 元気だねと　嘘をつくのも genkidaneto usootukunomo 優しさだと 分かっているけど yasashisadato wakatteirukedo 吐息だけでも いいから toikidakedemo iikara 辛い夜は　聴かせてとただ願うよ turaiyoruwa kikasetetotadanegauyo 幸せの意味が　離れてわかったの shiawasenoimiga hanaretewakattano 何気ない話がもっと　　したいのに nanigenaihanashigamotto shitainoni 素直になれない所だけ　似ているよ sunaoninarenaitokorodake niteiruyo 響く息をふと hibikuikiwo huto すぐに会いに行きたいけど suguni ainiikitaikedo 君はもう 違う誰かの　ものだから kimihamoo tigaudarekano monodakara でもたまに　吐息だけでもいいから demotamani toikidakedemo iikara どうしようもない位に doushiyoumonaikuraini 涙が 溢れて namidaga afurete 辛い夜は　電話かけても　いいかな turaiyoruwa denwakaketemo iikana

You guys have to remember that the Jpnese language is gonna have a different feel and sound to it than the Korean or Chinese version. Japanese vocals dont have to be strong and powerful. I think this works well because its really light sounding and cute.

I'm the only one who is going to talk about the actress? Ok... she is not the korean innocent and annoying type,people! This is probably a miracle... I totally love how Changmin seems shy here,instead of her. God bless that Beauty >.

why krystal so charming.. amazing,,, beautifull... i love her so much..

今も不意に聴きたくなる歌。切なくて美しい。 チャンミン。 やっぱり好きだなぁ。。。

changmin looks so young

I don't see the matter with Krystal's voice. Her voice is perfect to me ; it matches really well with Changmin's knowing both have high pitch tones. It gives a new soothing feeling to the song in my point of view. There are three different versions for this song and we can't compared the singers because they have not the same experience and each one interprets and expresses the song differently. Each one has its own charm.

Changmin's lovely voice and high notes omg.

Max changmin is the best!!!

Chang Min no.1

Max ChangMin!! Why are you so handsome, so talent?????

歌詞 出てはいけないと分かってたのに「やぁ、久しぶりだね」 電話の声が震えてすぐに 後悔がため息へと変わっていく 出てくれるわけないと思ってたから ごめん、声にならないの 今どこで何してるかも 聞けなくて 涙が出る 思いが言葉にならない 耳に響く息の音 「元気だよ」と嘘をつくのも 優しさだと分かってるけど 吐息だけでもいいから 今夜だけ 聞かせてほしい このまま ねえ君は新しい恋を もう始めたんだね あなたより素敵な人なんて いないのに 心をだまして 空しい恋してるよ 耳に響く息の音 「元気でね」と嘘をつくのも 優しさだと分かってるけど 吐息だけでもいいから つらい夜は 聞かせてと ただ願うよ 幸せの意味が 離れて分かったの 何気ない話がもっと したいのに 素直になれないとこだけ似てるよ 響く息の音 すぐに会いに行きたいけど 君はもう違う誰かのものだから でも、たまに 吐息だけでもいいから どうしようもないくらいに 涙が溢れて つらい夜は 電話かけてもいいかな

how come Chang min can look young an mature at the same time in this movie... when he played as school boy, he looks no gap age with moon ga young... love this movie, even sad ending... and of course the ost....

ENG VERSION PLZZ!!!! Tiffany and Henry can sing it!! I'M really sure their voices suit that song perfectly well!

Just finished the drama and my eyes hurt.. I didn't think I would cry that much, but it was so touching that left me with a warmth and sadness feeling ;; It was truly a beautiful story~ Changmin and Moon Ga young were great in their roles .. and I can't believe I want them to be together in real life too, but she's just too pretty and looks great with Changmin..

Listening in 2021. Such a shame we didn't hear this live, not even once. :( SM, drop the recording videos if you have it please!

Changmin is the best ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Shim Changmin and Krystal Jung Hwaiting!

I don't understand why people hate her, she's so talented and gorgeous like her sister!!!!!!

창민아 너무 너무 좋다

📢📢 I LOVE KRYSTAL

Lovely calm song of Max... one thing about Max is that I feel good and peaceful when I hear his voice... 

チャンミンさん、クリスタルちゃん、今年のSMTOWN　TOKYOでこの曲歌ってくれないかな? 二人の声がとても素敵で合っていて、一度生で聴きたいです♥♥♥

wow krystal's voice sounds like a real Japanese :DD

3 versions of this song are great, I like each of their vocals, but when I saw Moon Ga-young's acting alongside Max Changmin, this was completely sheer pandemonium....

I miss 2nd gen so much.. group collab, co-ed group, every groups have each different concept and distinct colors.

Changmin is always better with Japanese song. Spilling out his voice character more.

日本語上手です😊 切ない歌です。 ジョンヒョンとテヨンとはまた違う歌声で、好きです👍 ジョンヒョンの事、思い出されます。

チャンミンほんとかっこよすぎじゃん、スジョンめちゃくちゃ美しいじゃん、素敵

Changmin's voice is flawless. Love him.

Oh god I just realised how much Krystal sound like Jessica. Like yes I know they are sisters but I couldn't find anything similar before XD

チャンミンとスジョン最高 TT ほんとこの歌いい💜

I am waiting for krystals first album so badly 💜💜💜💜💜 her voice is so amazing and she sings so good and so beautiful and popular I really don't understand , what do SM waiting for she must have an album 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Dang Krystal sounded like Sica LOL!

Ooohhh! Changmin as I love you! TVXQ FOREVER!

Oh his voice is melting me!

Changmin ❤❤Where's Changmin 's fans？

Unusual, supposedly like korean better but i think this Japanese version is the best one, they succeed reveal the emotion and painful hearts in this song. I'm so touched.♡

This vers is my fav bc Changmin voice

今、この時間に聞いてる🫣切ない

2020, anyone?

This version is the best.

oh my god why am i just finding out that the japanese version is sung by changmin and krystal wow shoot me now ffff im gonna cry its too beautiful

Krystal is so versatile. She does everything so well! Love her! Soojung

love changmin's voice

Wow Krystal voice is just like Jessica :)

Changmin forever Your smile 🌻🌻 Your voice 🌸🌸 Your visual 💯 💯

Love changmin voice 😍😍 I think this version are the best among the 3 ver..their voice are really match...i hope they can sing live together😭😭😭

Changmin never fails to impress me♡ His voice is so perfect.

I think we should all just shush and stop being an arse. I mean, this song is pretty darn hard to sing and people have barely congratulated Krystal on her obvious improvements on being able to sing this song. She sounds good. Maybe her voice doesn't match Changmin's range, but she's still hitting all the notes and pulling her own. I applaud her for her vocal improvement and for landing this role. And yeah, Changmin's awesome. That's never changed.

OMG Changmin!!!! I'm so breathless X___X Lately I just realized that Krystal sounds like Sica...

定期的に聴きにくるんだけど、もう9年前の曲なのか

Changmin💓💓💓

In my opinion, I think Chinese version is full of sad emotions. Because of language and singers' expressions. I cried for Chinese version even my first listening and I didn't know the meaning of it at all. But for me, Japanese version gives me the relevant feeling of song's theme defined in description. Japanese version makes me feel like they're real teenage couple who has just broken up. And I also like their voices, too. Many people say that Krystal's voice is irritating or don't match with Changmin's voice or anyway but I think their voices are good together. I'm not f(x)'s fan. I'm Cassiopeia. I'm impassive with Krystal but for this work, I'm impressive with her singing.

I don't understand some people. They call themselves f(x) fans but I see a lot of 'f(x) fans' bashing on Krystal. I actually see Krystal having the most hates out of f(x) actually. Is it just me who noticed this or what?

切ないストーリーと気持ちが伝わってくる名曲。

これみたらいつも泣きそうになる😢チャンミン大好き♡

Jung Krystal, why both your voice and your face are beautiful? Seriously, you are very beautiful and i'm amazed of your beauty.

I really want to see them on the stage performing this song.

Okay....now I'm lost .-. I don't know which of the three versions I like the most. They are all fabulous

この組み合わせ好き💕 クリスタルやっぱり、シカ様の妹やね 笑 歌声そっくり😂